The New York Times: Best Pictures (2024)

The New York Times: Best Pictures (1) The New York Times: Best Pictures (2) The New York Times: Best Pictures (3)
Introduction Browse by Decade
The New York Times: Best Pictures (4) 1929-1939
The New York Times: Best Pictures (5) 1940-1949
The New York Times: Best Pictures (6) 1950-1959
The New York Times: Best Pictures (7) 1960-1969
The New York Times: Best Pictures (8) 1970-1979
The New York Times: Best Pictures (9) 1980-1989
The New York Times: Best Pictures (10) 1990-1999
The New York Times: Best Pictures (11) 2000-2002 Past Winners
The New York Times: Best Pictures (12) Actors
The New York Times: Best Pictures (13) Actresses
The New York Times: Best Pictures (14) Supp. Actors
The New York Times: Best Pictures (15) Supp. Actresses
The New York Times: Best Pictures (16) Directors Photos & Posters Help About "Best Pictures" The New York Times: Best Pictures (17) The New York Times: Best Pictures (18) The New York Times: Best Pictures (19) The New York Times: Best Pictures (20)
September 19, 1980 REVIEW | 'ORDINARY PEOPLE' Redford's 'Ordinary People' By VINCENT CANBY

The Jarretts are of the Wasp family now common in most parts of the continental United States. They are Calvin Jarrett, a successful tax lawyer, Beth, his immaculately pretty wife, who runs the family as if life were something to be organized like a tennis tournament, and 18-year-old Conrad, their surviving son, 14 months younger than Bucky Jarrett, who died a year and a half earlier.

The Jarretts are ordinary people, but they are extraordinarily privileged. They live in upper-middle-class splendor in Lake Forest, still Chicago's poshest suburb, and though the Jarretts don't live on a scale comparable to that of the ''old'' Lake Forest families, whose pre-World War I fortunes had their origins in meat packing, banking, railroading and mail-order retailing, they inhabit a beautiful house that is much too big for them, have two cars, a country-club membership and can afford vacations anywhere in the world whenever it suits them.

In her spare, efficient, best-selling novel, Judith Guest, seemingly without trying, dissected the contemporary white Anglo-Saxon Protestant psyche when, by accident, such perfect order is destroyed. Recently achieved economic and social privilege is no defense against emotional chaos. Privilege is a plywood treehouse in a hurricane.

The very real achievement of Robert Redford, who makes his directorial debut with ''Ordinary People,'' and of Alvin Sargent, who meticulously adapted Miss Guest's novel for the screen, is that the Jarretts become important people without losing their ordinariness, without being patronized or satirized. ''Ordinary People,'' which opens today at the Loews Tower East, is a moving, intelligent and funny film about disasters that are commonplace to everyone except the people who experience them. Not since Robert Benton's ''Kramer vs. Kramer'' has there been a movie that so effectively catches the look, sound and temper of a particular kind of American existence.

The Jarretts are not only ordinary people, they are also ''nice'' people. They wear the right clothes, read the right books, eat the right things and misbehave discreetly. They put great store in selfcontrol, as much in the privacy of their own house as abroad in the company of friends or strangers. The problem is that such niceness and control cannot accommodate the fears, furies and resentments occasioned when things go to pieces.

At the start of ''Ordinary People,'' young Conrad Jarrett (Timothy Hutton) has been home from the hospital for just a month and is trying very hard to resume life – school, the swimming team, the glee club – as if, five months earlier, he hadn't attempted suicide by slashing his wrists. Anyone looking at Conrad can tell that he is a wreck. He doesn't eat. He's nervous and he's too quick to say whatever he knows his mother and father want to hear.

Though Calvin (Donald Sutherland) worries about Conrad, he is unable to do much more than be enthusiastic in response to everything Conrad says. Beth (Mary Tyler Moore), resolutely pretends that there's nothing wrong with her son. She goes about her daily routine of golf, tennis, bridge and committee meetings with the determination not of someone living the good life in suburbia, but of a woman climbing Everest. Her jaw is set. She doesn't look back or down.

She's quite right when she says at one point, ''We'd have been all right if there hadn't been any mess.'' The Jarretts's ''mess'' was the accidental drowning of Bucky Jarrett one summer afternoon when he and Conrad were sailing together on Lake Michigan. Bucky, the strong one, gave up and drifted away from the overturned boat. Conrad survived, in guilt and sorrow, but when he realized he couldn't be the son Bucky was, he chose suicide.

More than five months after the suicide attempt, Conrad is in even worse shape than before. His mother, he tells the psychiatrist, will never forgive him for, among other things, having ruined the bathroom rug when he cut his wrists. ''She had to pitch it out,'' he says. ''They even had to regrout the tile floor.''

In several ways, Mr. Redford's film is far more effective than the novel. It's difficult to write about people who cannot talk to each other because writing is itself a kind of talking. Mr. Redford's film demonstrates this lack of communication, the inability to express affection, in scenes of sometimes overwhelming pathos – a Christmas Day gone all to hell for Conrad when his mother, as if in reflex, refuses to have her picture taken with her son.

Though ''Ordinary People'' focuses on the rehabilitation of Conrad, mostly through the efforts of a wise, understanding, quick-witted psychiatrist, played by Judd Hirsch, the film's most interesting character is Beth Jarrett, a Bonwit Teller lady hanging onto her sanity by fingertips made of steel.

Miss Moore is remarkably fine, simultaneously delicate and tough and desperate. The only reason she doesn't dominate the film is that all the other performances are equally good. Mr. Hutton is excellent in the difficult role of the deeply troubled boy, a nascent jock who, had there been no accident, might have gone through life always in second place and growing nothing much more than a slight paunch. Mr. Sutherland realizes his best film role in years, playing a fellow who, filled with love for both his wife and his son, is angrily accused by each of fence-sitting, of being weak and indecisive when he's really the only one in the family with some idea of what is wrong.

The supporting roles are splendidly handled by Mr. Hirsch, by a sweet newcomer named Elizabeth McGovern, as the girl who falls in love with Conrad despite Conrad's conviction that he is a no-good kid, and by Dinah Manoff, in the brief but splashy role of a young woman who shared Conrad's time in the psychiatric hospital.

Mr. Redford's appreciation for his actors is apparent, but it is also disciplined. ''Ordinary People'' doesn't look like any director's first movie. With the exception of fleeting flashbacks, which are necessary, I suppose, for exposition, the film's manner is cool, gentle, reserved. It never forces the emotions. It watches them erupt and allows us to make of them what we will, that is, until the last few minutes.

Though the film's ending approximates the novel's, it doesn't play very well on the screen. It's ordinary in the least interesting cinematic way. That, however, may be nit-picking. ''Ordinary People'' is otherwise so good – so full of rare feeling – that it would be presumptuous for a critic to attempt to re-edit it.

ORDINARY PEOPLE

Directed by Robert Redford; screenplay by Alvin Sargent, based on a novel by Judith Guest; director of photography, John Bailey; edited by Jeff Kanew; music adapted by Marvin Hamlisch; produced by Ronald L. Schwary; released by Paramount Pictures. At Loews Tower East, Third Avenue and 72d Street. Running time: 124 minutes. This film is rated R.

With Donald Sutherland, Mary Tyler Moore, Judd Hirsch, Timothy Hutton, M. Emmet Walsh, Elizabeth McGovern and Dinah Manoff

The New York Times: Best Pictures (21) The New York Times: Best Pictures (22)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (23)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (24)
Mary Tyler Moore and Donald Sutherland in "Ordinary People." (Paramount Pictures)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (25)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (26)• 'Ordinary People': Robert Redford Goes Behind the Camera for a New Image
The New York Times: Best Pictures (27)• 'Ordinary People': Meet the New Director: Robert Redford of 'Ordinary People'
The New York Times: Best Pictures (28)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (29)• Slide Show: Photos 1980-1989
The New York Times: Best Pictures (30)• Slide Show: Posters 1980-1989
The New York Times: Best Pictures (31)
The New York Times: Best Pictures (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Pres. Carey Rath

Last Updated:

Views: 6143

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Pres. Carey Rath

Birthday: 1997-03-06

Address: 14955 Ledner Trail, East Rodrickfort, NE 85127-8369

Phone: +18682428114917

Job: National Technology Representative

Hobby: Sand art, Drama, Web surfing, Cycling, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Leather crafting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Pres. Carey Rath, I am a faithful, funny, vast, joyous, lively, brave, glamorous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.